In order to find the top assisted living communities in the Saint Augustine area, our team of researchers:

  • Sorted through 43 communities using our unique methodology
  • Spent over 15 hours researching assisted living communities in Saint Augustine
  • Read more than 95 reviews left by residents and their family members

After filtering out facilities that didn’t meet our high standards, we were left with 10 assisted living communities that earned our seal of approval. Through this process we discovered that the average cost of assisted living in the city of Saint Augustine is $4,263, which is considerably higher than the state average of $3,500 and the national average of $4,051.

Christina Drumm-Boyd
Certified Senior Advisor (CSA) and Geriatric Care Manager (GCM)
Christina Drumm-Boyd
Certified Senior Advisor (CSA) and Geriatric Care Manager (GCM)

Christina is a Certified Senior Advisor (CSA) and Geriatric Care Manager (GCM) who is passionate about seniors and their families. Along with her staff, Christina works hands-on with each client to find the best solutions for the challenges that often come with aging.

Read on for in-depth information about the top assisted living facilities in Saint Augustine, a brief dive into our methodology for determining the best assisted living communities, and a searchable directory of 43 communities in the Saint Augustine area. Trusted Communities spent dozens of hours researching the top assisted living communities in the Saint Augustine area to allow seniors and their families to find the community that’s right for them. Click through the facilities listed below to read in-depth reviews, what residents are saying, and details such as base pricing, room types, and more.

Allegro - St. Augustine
Studios, 1-Bedroom Apartments, 2-Bedroom Apartments
Assisted Living, Independent Living
Not Listed
Located on Anastasia Island just south of the city's historic downtown core, Allegro - St. Augustine brings together the freedom of retirement with the relief of maintenance-free living. The community offers a full range of premier amenities, including a library, fitness center, games room and movie theater. Across the grounds, residents can enjoy walking paths, fountains, a pond and gazebo. Services, such as scheduled transportation and housekeeping, are offered to enhance residents' overall well-being. Delicious, chef-prepared meals are served three times daily, and residents have the option to enjoy them with friends in the restaurant-style dining room or in the privacy and comfort of their personal suite.
What Residents are Saying:
Family members mention the community's cleanliness, along with the community's activities and dining experience. One daughter says, "Everything is five-star. Their rooms are beautiful. Their dining room is very nice. They have everything like field trips. What I like best about this community is the staff and the cleanliness and that it is new and pretty."
4.92 out of 5 stars
(26) Reviews
1101 Plantation Island Drive S, St. Augustine, FL 32080
Bayview Assisted Living
Benton House of St. Johns
Brookdale St. Augustine
Coral Landing
Golden House Assisted Living
Riverside Cottages at the Shores
Silver Creek
Silver Treasures at St. Augustine
Westminster St. Augustine

Our Methodology

It’s not what we research, but the way we research that makes stand out. We start by identifying problems and challenges in the senior care industry by gaining insight from conversations with industry professionals, older adults, and those that care for them. Next, our research team led by industry experts apply our data-driven research techniques to understand the magnitude of the challenge and how to overcome it. Finally, we present our findings in easy-to-understand guides and studies and share our actionable results with influencers and caregivers, as well as the general public.

Facility Features (40%)

Facility Health Services Graded on health services provided
on the facility including, but not
limited to, on-site nursing,
pharmacy, skilled nursing,
medicine administration, etc

Facility Amenities Graded on the available

Affordability Financial assistance acceptance
and overall costs and value.

Residential Quality (40%)

Resident Satisfaction Polling & survey of overall facility satisfaction.

Facility Complaint and Violations Number of complaints and violations the facility had. Taking into account improvement over time.

Online Reviews Aggregated verified online reviews.

Location (20%)

Location-Based Benefits Including, but not limited to, proximity to
hospitals, ambulance response times, senior
resources available, and state and city
financial assistance.

Location Quality Local crime rates, incidents against older
adults, air quality, climate.

Assisted Living Directory Tool

Quickly search our comprehensive directory

Show Filters
Finance Options:
Property Info:
Health Services:

Showing of Communities